Showing posts with label human nature. Show all posts
Showing posts with label human nature. Show all posts

Friday, March 12, 2010

Philosophical Context: Human Nature

Human life is a balancing act. The cultures humans make are prone to imbalance.

The human creature contains various capacities and tendencies. Like all living beings, they have the capacity to regenerate. Additionally, they have the capacity to sense the outside world (sight, hearing, touch, taste, pain, pleasure, etc.) and the inside world (hunger, thirst, tiredness, etc.). Upon these senses are built the abstract capacities to emote, imagine, and rationalize.

The tendencies are psychological predispositions. The philosophical traditional with all of its disputants rarely agrees on any topic. In judging human nature, notably, most philosophers concede that humans are self-interested and social. By self-interested, they usually mean that a given individual will under normal circumstances do what is most advantageous for himself. By social, they usually mean that a given individual will under normal circumstances be happier and more prosperous should he be integrated into a social circle (both in the sense of friendships as well as societal relationships like those established in commerce and politics). The two are related insofar as the self does not contain enough material to meet all the needs of the self, and thus others are necessary for flourishing.

Beyond these well-documented tendencies, I would add two more: slothfulness and starvation. People, like all bodies, are given to taking the path of least resistance. Be it ease of physical progress (e.g. walking around a barrier rather than climbing over it) or mental progress (e.g. thinking of immediate, accessible subjects rather than training to think through more abstract subjects), people are prone to choose what is easiest. A person is more apt to find something to see or do than something to live for and more readily serves the seen rather than unseen.

People, like all bodies, are mired in a process of ultimate depletion. Like all life, humans are prone to disease and ultimately death. These can be hastened either by atrophy of the capacities or disregard for the tendencies. To subsist, people must replenish what they lose. Satiety does not only apply properly to the stomach. The eyes need to see enough, the ears need to hear enough, the flesh needs to be touched and to touch enough. (This is why we need the arts and natural beauty: because they provide for us that which sustains our most central outer senses.) The capacities exist in a range of fullness to emptiness.

The human heart abhors a vacuum and some form of discontent accompanies an intuition of a lack. As pain is the ambassador of physical regeneration, discontent is the ambassador of immaterial regeneration. With so many capacities that require filling, it is easy to become malnourished. Each of these facets requires specific sustenance with a specific material to make it healthy. Flourishing is a level of satiety across the span of personality. The multifaceted nature of humans gives provides a plurality of sources of discontent.

The individual is a whole made up of many parts: body and mind. We must refrain from taking the division too literally. The parts are interrelated; they form a plurality within the unity we call the self or soul. The individual is then like a web: when one point is pulled, the others are strained towards it. Pain often incites emotion. Depression soon becomes the mood of a person suffering from chronic undernourishment. The quality of his thoughts decreases and soon his body suffers from an immune system weakened by dejection.

All of the capacities share a need to be exercised and most share the quality of being intuitable (i.e., made conscious). Regeneration is the only unconscious, unwilled capacity. The ability to grow and heal is limited largely be uncontrollable factors. One has no direct (i.e., intuited) awareness of growing taller, of healing, of replenishing depleted nutrients. All capacities are capable of decaying, and thereby require regeneration. To see to it that the aspects of regeneration which are voluntary are take place, one of the capacities--the capacity for pain--often activates. Being self-interested, the subject is enticed to utilize the dormant capacity. The discomfort of prolonged hunger is one such instance that spurs a person to eat.

One form of straining upon the web we call stress. If there could be a national malady, ours would be stress. The basal discomfort associated with too many tasks, victimization by supervisors or siblings, health issues, and all other lamentable states, make us more susceptible to the slightest additional discomforts. What appears to reason alone as unrelated can nevertheless be causally significant. By the logic of human holism, one cannot tolerate silence because one has too many school assignments. A pebble in the shoe can make a tyrant.

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Ricochet

David Hume asks you to imagine that you had never seen before two objects colliding. Although you know everything you know now, you have no understanding of the physics involved in a collision. What might you predict would happen when a moving billiard ball strikes a stationary one? For all you know, a ball traveling north strikes a still ball and bounces southward. Equally as plausible, perhaps both balls move northward after impact. would it be so impossible for the balls, squarely struck as they may have been, to dart off on to the west and one to the east? How profound our ignorance of cause and effect! Had we never experienced physics, we'd never be able to project the state of the world into the future.
I must confess that we have as much a priori predictive power in regards to human affairs as we do the ways of the world. The original situation is merely a thought-experiment (and therefore a matter concerning only academic-types). The latter situations--who must not admit that he is in such a state of ignorance regarding his fellow humans? When we don't allow our biases and prejudices to be active, could we guess which way a person will break when running into a stationary object? (Life is a series of stationary objects that people bounce off of in one way or another.) Will a given person bounce to the right, say to become indignant, after running into a demotion? Or will she instead bounce to the left, say to resign herself to her new position. Will she bounce straight back and attack her boss, or will she continue forward and quit the company? That possibilities are various and the truth is we never know which way a person will break.
Here is a tricky thing about life: we cannot always trust the explanations proffered for one's actions. Take the following example: a certain woman appears generous. You take to observing her. She gives sundry gifts to her friends and family with frequency. She gives beyond her means, always taking wealth from herself and passing it around. She lavishes her circle with fancy cards on top and wrapping paper around the gifts, and often does not even stay near-by to watch them opened. She is pleased at a distance. The onslaught flatters her circle. Whenever she finds herself in an altercation with one of its members, she draws upon her philanthropic activities to mitigate her responsibilities. You watch this and think, she must be after something with all those gifts. Perhaps she wants approval or appreciation. Perhaps she just wants acceptance. Whatever the case may be, the sheer volume of her gift-giving is suspicious. You suggest in passing that she is to some extent "buying the love of others." At this, she explodes. "I have never done anything of the sort! I like being nice to people and showing them how much they mean to me!" Does her response count against your hypothesis? Is the violence with which she retorted further validation? It could be that she is buying the love of others and is not conscious of it. She could know that it would be ill-intentioned to be giving with such motives and thus respond negatively at the accusation. It could be that you have misread the situation. Perhaps the distance she takes after giving is humility.
Is there anything to gain from our own cases? Which way will you break? Don't you know. Ah! You are ignorant even of yourself. Poke and prod as a good scientist does and you chink your own armor.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

A Question of Agency

May 1, 2009

Nature, properly speaking, is not an agent. Agency is a characteristic of persons. Persons are, amongst other things, those beings that can fit their means to their ends. Persons can choose their actions and thereby ennoble their goals. Not everything that acts, chooses. Nature and all strictly natural phenomena do not choose.

There is a tendency, consequent of our anthro-centrism, to think in terms of agency--even regarding nature and natural phenomena. A case in point: natural selection. To select is to choose, to scan a field and endorse one option over others. Selection is only available to agents. Yet, natural selection is one of the most commonly referenced attributes of nature. Linguistically, this houses a confusion. Nature does not select species to survive anymore than a trash can selects to be gray. A more proper term, free from agency baggage, would be natural action.

Only agents can be subject to questions of why. Nature, an object--the object, can only admit questions of how. When a person poses to herself the question, "Why me?" to whom is she addressing? Herself? No--selfhood is not a choice, it is a given. Nature? No--nature does not choose, it gives (and takes) solely in the sense that it does, not that it decides to do. Can there be any other appeal to this most interior of questions? Is the disavowal of any other subject--the Subject--liberating? Does a person, when they deny a greater agency, gain greater fulfillment? Is a victory worthwhile when it is thin--when one responds to the question, "Why me?" with "Don't ask,"? Ought we rebel against this natural questioning tendency, our disposition to address the wider world as an agent? Or does the persistence of this question suggest that there is something real that is at once real and not natural?

Unnaturally Natural or Naturally Unnatural?

May 1, 2009

Our minds never tire of raising certain grandiose questions. How could consciousness ever be constructed out of unconscious materials? How could dead matter ever combine, on its own, to become living?

Some respond to the persistent mystery surrounding the answers to those questions as proof of their nonsensicality. Nature tends, by her impersonal machinations, to prefer individuals to survive and perpetuate their winning traits. At times, however, accidental traits pass-on and endure. These accidents are those attributes of individuals that do not secure their survival (initially) and there perpetuation (eventually). These superfluous mutations remain, so long as they do not hinder nature's ends. If the mutations are disadvantageous, then those individuals and the species they belong to become extinct. Humanity's great mutation, the peculiar extent of their consciousness, has been of the utmost benefit to them. Never before has adaptation been so swift and fluid. More than any other animal, humans exploit their surroundings, thereby securing their survival and perpetuation.

Aspects of consciousness are not of equal import. Some aspects of consciousness, like those questions posed in perennial philosophy, fail to meet either of the two basic needs for which nature selects. To the extent that consciousness does not benefit the species, it is accidental. That we can at once ponder and not benefit by pondering questions concerning consciousness and life demonstrates the accidental, mutated quality of philosophical thought. We can study those frustrating questions to offer hypotheses as to how they ever could have arisen, but we will always treat them as a sixth toe or second head: a grotesque curiosity.

Some respond to the persistent mystery surrounding the answers to those questions as proof of their necessity. Because of the precarious position consciousness and life have in the natural world, they are distinguished from it. Rather than calling them natural and supposing they do not belong, they are called supernatural and supposed to belong elsewhere.

If we were never perpetuated by wondering about certain truths, why can we not be rid of questions? How could something spring from nature that is so patently unnatural? Could it be that there is something unnatural in us?

Nature commands: live and then die! A human's interiority commands: live! Either humans are fundamentally deranged (at once mindful of part of what nature requires and resistant to the other) or they are in some way transcendent.