Allow me to take inventory now that we have traveled so far. We have observed that childhood and adulthood are opposed when viewed as temporal phenomena. A person of thirty is no longer a child in the sense that he has become too much, had too many opportunities to be considered a child. Yet, if we reflect upon ourselves we noted that childhood and adulthood are less definitively related. Neither memories nor dreams entail compatibility or opposition between being a child and being an adult. In this light, childhood and adulthood behave like qualitative states of being. Qualities are always more elusive than quantities and their definitions tend to be suspect. Much thought needs to be exerted to distinguish qualities. One never knows them for certain, but rather gets a taste for them.
Being obligated to meditate further on aging as a quality, let us try to differentiate further. What are some of the commonplace understandings of our subject? A child is ignorant, prone to self-gratification, and free from responsibility. An adult is rational, prone to self-sacrifice, and burdened by duties. Children are dreamers. Adults are realists. A child will cry when he does not get his way. An adult has learned to control his emotions in disagreeable circumstances. Children are clumsy. Adults are careful. A child is helpless. An adult is autonomous. A child needs help even to go to sleep. An adult can go to sleep on her own.
Is there no common ground amongst the prejudices? Why is it that when we looked at a given man's life we saw subtle transitions but when we consider conventional wisdom all we see are contrasts once more? Could it be that conventional wisdom is propounded by adults, a party interested in its own image?
From our list, it appears that childhood is inferior to adulthood. What could a child have that is superior to her older counterpart? I must interject and suggest that the child has a great gift in innocence. The pride in adults thinks it is better to be credited than to be blameless. They (and I with them) need to admit that it is always better to be blameless than to be blamed and often better to be blameless than to be credited.
To be innocent, one must not have done something. Children are innocent for at least two reasons: (1) they do not do the same sort of things adults do and (2) they do not know as much as adults do. With increased autonomy comes greater trust--trust in personal and professional relationships. Children, being largely dependent, are saved from the opportunity to do wrong. With increased autonomy comes greater awareness--awareness of morals and mortals (i.e., one's contemporaries). Children, being largely dependent, are saved from the knowledge of doing wrong. It is the childishness of children, so frequently used to disparage adults, that allows them to be so innocent. It is the maturity of adults, so frequently used to commend children, that allows them to be so often guilty.
Childhood has its weaknesses and dangers. Conventional wisdom speaks to those. It is a different sort of dangerous to get older though, and yet we must get older.
These hands that type were once too small and confusedly operated to communicate through words. God willing, they will someday be too contorted and perhaps confusedly operated to communicate through words again. I pass through this process. We all do. Yet, the hands remain our own and the same. How are they the same? In a distant way, like the first prototypes of technologies relate to today's state of the art? Or intimately like an old pine floor with a new coat of wax on it?
When a baby is displeased, is crying and unsettled, a loving parent takes her up into her arms. She walks with her child, dips her shoulders, and rhythmically rocks her. The baby is lulled by the expectations of the movement and their certain fulfillment. Now the move to the left; now the move to the right. If need be, she whispers sweet shushes and reaffirms serenity with words. The baby knows both only by their calming affect. Now the baby sleeps and the parent is pleased. Finally, the struggling child rests. But--what if the child wanted food? What if the child had soiled herself? What if she was pained by the onset of a fever? The benign, dreamy face masks the original problem.
Can an adult be lulled to sleep? I concede that he or she is often unsettled and would be well-pleased by a lullaby, but it is impossible. An adult is too sophisticated, too self-conscious, to be tricked by the gentle whispers of nonsense. A man or woman cannot easily be taken up into the arms of a loving parent. The cause of distress if far more complex, weighty, and intransigent--in a word, far more adult.
What about alternatives? Is there no way to rock an adult to sleep in a metaphorical way? Have they absolutely outgrown being coddled, or could there be a more sophisticated form? Is there now a different sort of rocking device--a surrogate parent?
A common experience among people transitioning from dependence to independence is persistent doubt. A person develops, matures, grows, physically and mentally, but not without restriction. Diet, gravity, and self-awareness all hinder the process of growth. A young man or women is frequently riddled by self-doubt. An undercurrent surges beneath the placid surface. Is this a good way to make a living? Is this what I was meant to do? Where am I going? An adult is bound to tear up and kick if they reflect much longer on this uncertain state. Somewhere they know there are needs going unmet, but it would be so difficult to meet them. It would be much easier to be distracted. Now our young man or woman wants to be put to sleep, in the disarmed reality of unconsciousness.
Give a person a routine, and he will be calmed. He has his definition; he knows the floor he is at. He thinks of himself as a worker. There is a position on his identification badge that fixes him in place. The rhythm of adulthood mollifies him. A morning cup of coffee is his new pacifier. The bumps along the commute provide the rocking motion. Now the acceleration to gain access to the needed lane; now the deceleration to abide by the traffic light's command. Discomfort slinks back. What is now and pressing upon him is the cold but tight embrace of worldly responsibility. Those questions, which still lack answers, are displaced. The goals are immediate: pack a lunch, check the messages, file the papers, write the letter, clean the area. They are easily completed. Oh grace of grace--how they replenish! The world marches on and the inbox fills and refills. There is no time to consider discomfort--there is work to be done. All the while, the potential elevator drops.
Is there anything more dangerous for an adult than to be lulled when he needs to be awake? It is a state that precipitates a crash.
If a gentle woman were to come upon the worker who is at rest while being so active, addressed him by name, and asked whether he was awake--what would the man answer? "What a silly question--if I could answer, I must be awake. I am surely awake for I can tell you as much." She would then ask the follow up question: who is it that answers thus--the worker or the man? Now she has cornered him. He would pause and furrow his brow. "It has been so long since I recognized the difference, but you ask an apt question. For long ago, when I began this routine--I told myself, "This is what a person must do in an age like ours. I will take up this routine and take up the designation of worker, but it will not be me. No, I will keep myself neatly tucked away. I am tired and distressed. I will let my self rest and the worker in me will take over. I will return upon retirement and be full of energy and ready to address what ails me. Now here I am, frail and tucked in my sheets, and you have awoken me though I thought I was already awake. I was rocked to sleep and lost consciousness of my self in the process. Where is the worker now? Oh dreadful thought--that I was him this whole time!"
The gentle woman would pat him on the head, smooth over his disheveled curls, and explain to him that a person can never really be free from his self. Integrity describes a person's life even if he tries to disintegrate because a person is always the same book even when the chapter changes. The hand grows, but it remains at bottom the same hand.
Now those unanswered questions are free to return. Now he feels anxious. Now the tears begin to well. Woe to him whose elevator of actuality door opens at such a moment!
It would be so easy, so secure, if we could simply be content in being adults. Surely membership in such a group demands respect, both from self and others. Alas, it is not so easy. It is a dangerous group to be a part of.
--
Our analysis is far from complete. Books could be written on the subject and still the qualitative difference would remain as vague. Qualities are indiscrete, making the study of them at once frustrating and rewarding.
We have made many observations that the audience is free to remember or forget. From within thought, we may peer into growth's essence. We see a process of becoming. Growth is at once an automatic and perilous process. It is automatic like the progression of time; it is perilous like the firing of clay. From within life, we see growth in its existence. We reflect on our selves changing and remaining the same. We recall the centrality of ideals concerning a person's development.
Childhood is not devoid of value nor is adulthood abundant in it. How the two stages are related is neither inscrutable nor obvious. If given time, a child will become an adult. Attention is required along the way lest the child become something less laudable than the ideal of maturity suggests.
unsystematic writings that are philosophical in nature but not in approach
Showing posts with label aging. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aging. Show all posts
Monday, January 11, 2010
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Growth: The Literature of A Life
After stirring up the pot, I need to let the liquid settle. As an artist, I want to guide not disorient. Exhale with me, and allow me to return to my easel. I am inspired to paint a different picture of aging.
Picture: Books
The lives of people are like a compilation of short stories. The stories are kept in a book we call the self. Each story consists of spans of time differentiated by a central purpose. As a child, the purposes are often determined by others. These are the stories of innocence and learning. They are the memories of playtime and curiosity. A child increasingly becomes self-aware and thus begins to take up his pen to write his stories for himself. As a child ages, he is free to dissociate from the person he has been and determines his own purpose. At such point, he turns the page and begins the story anew.
If a person reflects upon her self in a general way--upon the things she feels, does, observes, and thinks--she finds recurring reasons for the characteristics of her self (e.g., her vices and virtues). These recurring reasons function like morals to a story, and thus the stories of youth transition into fables of adulthood. The reasons frame the structure of a person's motivation and suggest what a person holds dear. Imagine a woman who is angered when she is treated inconsiderately. Desiring to reap what she sews, she constantly takes the the feelings of others into consideration when making choices that involve them. Her motivation, a mixture of self-interest and empathy, suggests that people are valuable and they warrant influence upon each other's choices. We would expect to find at the close of many of her fables morals such as, "No one truly forgets injuries in the presence of him who caused the injury," and "The memory of a good deed lives."
We see that adulthood is complicated by the added layer of morals. The beginning of the adulthood commences with the beginning of self-determination. Independence is the mark of other aspects of growth. A child matures by overcoming immediacy. The muscles in the neck strengthen and rather than being stuck in the position gravity requires the baby hold her own head up to see what she wants. The muscles strengthen in her arms and legs and she goes where she wants by crawling. The muscles strengthen in her back and legs and she goes further by walking. The eyes see greater distances. The mind sees greater distances too. A child begins to want more than meeting physical needs. She wants to be something more than bodily contented because she has gained the ability to be something more. To transcend is the action of maturity.
I started seeing life in this way because of an old man I know. When I told him of this current investigation of mine, he voiced his desire to contribute. Being ever interested in the thoughts of sages, I accepted. On promise of anonymity, he handed the following essay to me. I will leave it to my readers to interpret it as they will, it being more direct than Brandon's contribution.
Story: Dreams
The balls of inertia people are begin to accelerate when we begin to consciously direct our lives towards a goal. When I see a child of the age where goals begin to be relevant, I wonder to myself, "What dream do you contain? What is your idea of perfection?" Nothing on the child's face suggests it. His clothes have nothing certain to offer. Yet, children certainly do have an idea of perfection, no matter how nebulous it is in their minds. It is their home, where they always return to.
There are so many possible ends and the specifics within a given person are telling about them. People do strange things--disingenuous things--when they feel the eyes of others upon them. Children are certainly conscious of being watched and often behave otherwise than they would if alone. Behavior resides in the public domain; dreams reside the private domain. The dreams of children are rarely touched by foreign hands for a child thinks nothing of the judgment of others upon their internal contents. Would a child dream a certain dream because his friends would approve? Would a child dream a certain dream because it is what her parents want? No, for the simple reason that they know--if only in a nascent way--dreams are born secrets. Who could ever discover those buried treasure chests?
I enjoy hypothesizing about the dreams a child contains when I see her: would it be a world without death? Would it be a world where you are well-liked and well-known? Would it be a world where you stand atop the scorched remains of your enemies? Would it be a world where everyone can sense beauty on a daily basis?
I wonder these things as I look at a child's busy eyes. I wonder what he or she would tolerate suffering for sake of his or her sweet little dream becoming real. I think about the ways children will try to bring it off, the ways they will succeed and the ways they will fail--the ways they will be confused as to what counts as success and failure. Will they persist when they are knocked back or when they trip? Will they move off in a different direction? Will they harden from the fire of disenchantment or will they melt from the fire of hope? Will they simply hunch over and sob for the remainder of their lives? Will they begin the process of growing older and start to reconstruct their ideas of perfection based off the blueprints of others' expectations?
These questions arise in my mind with such great consistency because I have come to understand myself by answering them. After many years of living, I see myself as playing out some sort of role that was fixed--fixed freely by my own choice--at the ripe age of thirteen. It has been the role of a dreamer in a lucid dream. I have dreamed up a world, unknowingly begun to live in it, and then through a strange coincidence come to understand my own power (and limitations) within the dreamworld. I have tried my best to make the world as real as possible without changing the essence of the first dream.
Providence has blessed me with a certain sort of stupidity that kept me from dreaming anything too like what happens in the world. I became enamored with a lofty vision. Many of the people I was near to as a child were unhappy. Their displeasure took pride of place in my heart as the most pressing need. In response to my environment, I dreamed of a world without suffering. To clarify, I did not think perfection lied in the cessation of all pain. I never saw anything wrong with scraped knees and paper cuts. The lessons to be gleaned from them were easy enough. What I dreamed of was a world without wanton suffering. I wanted everyone to be without all pain that had no hope of yielding edification. I wanted everyone to be free of the sort of sadness that merely disintegrated--the irrational sort of sickness that brought one to cry without any understanding of why the tears came. I thought perfection was a world free of depression and despair.
As a child, I never thought in such stark terms. The limitations of a youth's mind keep them benignly ignorant. I had only a hunch, an undeveloped notion I was infrequently aware of as being my guiding light. I knew it by the repulsion I felt whenever I encountered the depraved sort of suffering. Whenever confronted by it, my immediate and innocent impulse was to disarm it. (I have had for as long as I can remember a tepid but distinct savior complex. Tepid in that I never thought I would save the world. Distinct in that I thought I could save the people I knew.)
My tactics changed over the years. When I was young, I was more passionate than effective. Some of the time, I would try through words and other times I would try through deeds. I would try in my little child way to make sense of the pain aloud with the other person. Through interviewing, I would try to draw out the venom. I would try to think and talk through the semi-conscious pain, and then think and talk it away. I felt sure that if I could bring it out into the clear light of day, it would evaporate like morning mist.
My mother passed away shortly after I was born. Her sister, Clare, would come to our house on occasion to help us with domestic tasks. One occasion juts out in my memory as exemplary of my lucidity. I remember Clare was doing laundry. She had been sulking around the house before descending to the laundry room. I went to visit her in the basement, and noticed she was crying. At the time, my thinking was wonderfully simple: a person cries for a reason. I asked her what was wrong, and after a lengthy back and forth we concluded that the issue was frustration with her bodily appearance. It was my task to bring the world nearer to my ideal. I explained how inappropriate it was to think of your identity as primarily physical. Then, I criticized those who would devalue a person because of their appearance. I told her I loved her regardless. She smiled. All was well now, was it not? I was a successful psychologist already in sixth grade. Alas, I would always return to a place not too far from the starting point. Clare's sadness would boomerang back.
I became unsure of my healing ability. Some wounds resisted treatment. I went back to the drawing board. Perhaps something that was originally beyond words needed to be treated beyond words. When the thorn in my friend's side immediately appeared more stubborn than I could coax out by my teeth, I would apply my hands. I would put them on a person's shoulder blades and hug them. I would try to warm them, to melt the frost that chilled their insides. Alas, I would always return to a place not too far from the starting point. I learned that dusting a portrait does nothing to fix its broken frame.
Now, I look back on my early projects and understand myself better. I was onto something good with that first dream, but I was not onto the summum bonum. Far is the distance from "onto something" to "being there." A nose for food does not always bring you to the kitchen. Sometimes it takes you to the dumpster. Only later could I decipher that my turn outward was a way to keep me from myself. After the failures piled up--after I was unable to stop the bleeding of those sad individuals I knew--I was left alone in my room. Years later I realized that I was one of those sad individuals and had not given myself time to notice it out of some unconscious determination of self-preservation. It was a worthy dream, but needed alteration. Suffering warrants attention and requires a response, but the attendant may need attention of his own and the respondent may be insufficient for the response. Now, I still dream of a world without suffering but imagine myself in it and do not imagine myself creating it. I still strive to disarm despair, but do so in myself as well as others and avoid relying solely upon myself for success. A savior I am not.
Worth of the dream aside, can you see the explanatory power of these first goals? They are like keys that unlock the journal of the self. People spend the rest of their lives relating to these goals. Maturation is a process of revision upon these first goals that move us forward.
A person is free to abandon his first goal. Some simply forget what they were. Make no mistake, though. Goals are always present. Another goal slips into place as soon as one is jettisoned. Somewhere within a person are his reasons for living with their corollary emotional motivations.
The necessity of necessity in life is as a consistent source of motivation. The individuals who manage to draw upon a consistent source of motivation are those who are placed in the canon of people. They lead lives of integrity, with the sameness of purpose that pleases their audience like alliteration pleases readers. Some lives may be driven by towards ill ends, but we are nevertheless fascinated by their persistence. The singularity of purpose makes them memorable because it is so difficult to achieve. Discouragement comes and one is tempted to revise towards something easier and less lofty.
If a person does not concern himself with their fundamental motivation, then that person consigns himself to being forever a baby. To him I say, "Fine. Your life is your bet and you place it on purposelessness as truth. Good luck to you. But what would your winnings be and what do you jeopardize?"
Picture: Books
The lives of people are like a compilation of short stories. The stories are kept in a book we call the self. Each story consists of spans of time differentiated by a central purpose. As a child, the purposes are often determined by others. These are the stories of innocence and learning. They are the memories of playtime and curiosity. A child increasingly becomes self-aware and thus begins to take up his pen to write his stories for himself. As a child ages, he is free to dissociate from the person he has been and determines his own purpose. At such point, he turns the page and begins the story anew.
If a person reflects upon her self in a general way--upon the things she feels, does, observes, and thinks--she finds recurring reasons for the characteristics of her self (e.g., her vices and virtues). These recurring reasons function like morals to a story, and thus the stories of youth transition into fables of adulthood. The reasons frame the structure of a person's motivation and suggest what a person holds dear. Imagine a woman who is angered when she is treated inconsiderately. Desiring to reap what she sews, she constantly takes the the feelings of others into consideration when making choices that involve them. Her motivation, a mixture of self-interest and empathy, suggests that people are valuable and they warrant influence upon each other's choices. We would expect to find at the close of many of her fables morals such as, "No one truly forgets injuries in the presence of him who caused the injury," and "The memory of a good deed lives."
We see that adulthood is complicated by the added layer of morals. The beginning of the adulthood commences with the beginning of self-determination. Independence is the mark of other aspects of growth. A child matures by overcoming immediacy. The muscles in the neck strengthen and rather than being stuck in the position gravity requires the baby hold her own head up to see what she wants. The muscles strengthen in her arms and legs and she goes where she wants by crawling. The muscles strengthen in her back and legs and she goes further by walking. The eyes see greater distances. The mind sees greater distances too. A child begins to want more than meeting physical needs. She wants to be something more than bodily contented because she has gained the ability to be something more. To transcend is the action of maturity.
I started seeing life in this way because of an old man I know. When I told him of this current investigation of mine, he voiced his desire to contribute. Being ever interested in the thoughts of sages, I accepted. On promise of anonymity, he handed the following essay to me. I will leave it to my readers to interpret it as they will, it being more direct than Brandon's contribution.
Story: Dreams
The balls of inertia people are begin to accelerate when we begin to consciously direct our lives towards a goal. When I see a child of the age where goals begin to be relevant, I wonder to myself, "What dream do you contain? What is your idea of perfection?" Nothing on the child's face suggests it. His clothes have nothing certain to offer. Yet, children certainly do have an idea of perfection, no matter how nebulous it is in their minds. It is their home, where they always return to.
There are so many possible ends and the specifics within a given person are telling about them. People do strange things--disingenuous things--when they feel the eyes of others upon them. Children are certainly conscious of being watched and often behave otherwise than they would if alone. Behavior resides in the public domain; dreams reside the private domain. The dreams of children are rarely touched by foreign hands for a child thinks nothing of the judgment of others upon their internal contents. Would a child dream a certain dream because his friends would approve? Would a child dream a certain dream because it is what her parents want? No, for the simple reason that they know--if only in a nascent way--dreams are born secrets. Who could ever discover those buried treasure chests?
I enjoy hypothesizing about the dreams a child contains when I see her: would it be a world without death? Would it be a world where you are well-liked and well-known? Would it be a world where you stand atop the scorched remains of your enemies? Would it be a world where everyone can sense beauty on a daily basis?
I wonder these things as I look at a child's busy eyes. I wonder what he or she would tolerate suffering for sake of his or her sweet little dream becoming real. I think about the ways children will try to bring it off, the ways they will succeed and the ways they will fail--the ways they will be confused as to what counts as success and failure. Will they persist when they are knocked back or when they trip? Will they move off in a different direction? Will they harden from the fire of disenchantment or will they melt from the fire of hope? Will they simply hunch over and sob for the remainder of their lives? Will they begin the process of growing older and start to reconstruct their ideas of perfection based off the blueprints of others' expectations?
These questions arise in my mind with such great consistency because I have come to understand myself by answering them. After many years of living, I see myself as playing out some sort of role that was fixed--fixed freely by my own choice--at the ripe age of thirteen. It has been the role of a dreamer in a lucid dream. I have dreamed up a world, unknowingly begun to live in it, and then through a strange coincidence come to understand my own power (and limitations) within the dreamworld. I have tried my best to make the world as real as possible without changing the essence of the first dream.
Providence has blessed me with a certain sort of stupidity that kept me from dreaming anything too like what happens in the world. I became enamored with a lofty vision. Many of the people I was near to as a child were unhappy. Their displeasure took pride of place in my heart as the most pressing need. In response to my environment, I dreamed of a world without suffering. To clarify, I did not think perfection lied in the cessation of all pain. I never saw anything wrong with scraped knees and paper cuts. The lessons to be gleaned from them were easy enough. What I dreamed of was a world without wanton suffering. I wanted everyone to be without all pain that had no hope of yielding edification. I wanted everyone to be free of the sort of sadness that merely disintegrated--the irrational sort of sickness that brought one to cry without any understanding of why the tears came. I thought perfection was a world free of depression and despair.
As a child, I never thought in such stark terms. The limitations of a youth's mind keep them benignly ignorant. I had only a hunch, an undeveloped notion I was infrequently aware of as being my guiding light. I knew it by the repulsion I felt whenever I encountered the depraved sort of suffering. Whenever confronted by it, my immediate and innocent impulse was to disarm it. (I have had for as long as I can remember a tepid but distinct savior complex. Tepid in that I never thought I would save the world. Distinct in that I thought I could save the people I knew.)
My tactics changed over the years. When I was young, I was more passionate than effective. Some of the time, I would try through words and other times I would try through deeds. I would try in my little child way to make sense of the pain aloud with the other person. Through interviewing, I would try to draw out the venom. I would try to think and talk through the semi-conscious pain, and then think and talk it away. I felt sure that if I could bring it out into the clear light of day, it would evaporate like morning mist.
My mother passed away shortly after I was born. Her sister, Clare, would come to our house on occasion to help us with domestic tasks. One occasion juts out in my memory as exemplary of my lucidity. I remember Clare was doing laundry. She had been sulking around the house before descending to the laundry room. I went to visit her in the basement, and noticed she was crying. At the time, my thinking was wonderfully simple: a person cries for a reason. I asked her what was wrong, and after a lengthy back and forth we concluded that the issue was frustration with her bodily appearance. It was my task to bring the world nearer to my ideal. I explained how inappropriate it was to think of your identity as primarily physical. Then, I criticized those who would devalue a person because of their appearance. I told her I loved her regardless. She smiled. All was well now, was it not? I was a successful psychologist already in sixth grade. Alas, I would always return to a place not too far from the starting point. Clare's sadness would boomerang back.
I became unsure of my healing ability. Some wounds resisted treatment. I went back to the drawing board. Perhaps something that was originally beyond words needed to be treated beyond words. When the thorn in my friend's side immediately appeared more stubborn than I could coax out by my teeth, I would apply my hands. I would put them on a person's shoulder blades and hug them. I would try to warm them, to melt the frost that chilled their insides. Alas, I would always return to a place not too far from the starting point. I learned that dusting a portrait does nothing to fix its broken frame.
Now, I look back on my early projects and understand myself better. I was onto something good with that first dream, but I was not onto the summum bonum. Far is the distance from "onto something" to "being there." A nose for food does not always bring you to the kitchen. Sometimes it takes you to the dumpster. Only later could I decipher that my turn outward was a way to keep me from myself. After the failures piled up--after I was unable to stop the bleeding of those sad individuals I knew--I was left alone in my room. Years later I realized that I was one of those sad individuals and had not given myself time to notice it out of some unconscious determination of self-preservation. It was a worthy dream, but needed alteration. Suffering warrants attention and requires a response, but the attendant may need attention of his own and the respondent may be insufficient for the response. Now, I still dream of a world without suffering but imagine myself in it and do not imagine myself creating it. I still strive to disarm despair, but do so in myself as well as others and avoid relying solely upon myself for success. A savior I am not.
Worth of the dream aside, can you see the explanatory power of these first goals? They are like keys that unlock the journal of the self. People spend the rest of their lives relating to these goals. Maturation is a process of revision upon these first goals that move us forward.
A person is free to abandon his first goal. Some simply forget what they were. Make no mistake, though. Goals are always present. Another goal slips into place as soon as one is jettisoned. Somewhere within a person are his reasons for living with their corollary emotional motivations.
The necessity of necessity in life is as a consistent source of motivation. The individuals who manage to draw upon a consistent source of motivation are those who are placed in the canon of people. They lead lives of integrity, with the sameness of purpose that pleases their audience like alliteration pleases readers. Some lives may be driven by towards ill ends, but we are nevertheless fascinated by their persistence. The singularity of purpose makes them memorable because it is so difficult to achieve. Discouragement comes and one is tempted to revise towards something easier and less lofty.
If a person does not concern himself with their fundamental motivation, then that person consigns himself to being forever a baby. To him I say, "Fine. Your life is your bet and you place it on purposelessness as truth. Good luck to you. But what would your winnings be and what do you jeopardize?"
Thursday, January 7, 2010
Growth: The History of A Self
Just as people see in pictures, they understand in stories. Stories are causally related sequences of events. People relish causal trails, whether in narratives or not. No one wants to live in a world of random events. It makes sense to us that our front lawns are white when we look upon them now because it precipitated overnight and the air and ground temperatures were below the freezing point. Once we know the fundamentals of weather, we begin to presume its orderly functioning in our environment. People yearn for order and being led down the path of a story (even if it is fictional) puts us at ease. We enjoy knowing why what we perceive is the way that it is. These explanations dull the edge of mystery which is otherwise so apt to slice. The topsy-turvey world of disorder and ignorance is pacified by reasoning. Sickness becomes more bearable by knowing who gave us the cold, does it not? Perhaps we ought to seek an understanding of the link between adulthood and childhood rather than simply looking at it.
Brandon Hayes, whom I've introduced you to before, generously answered in writing a question I posed to him regarding aging. I asked him what events sprang to mind when he thought of his childhood. Below are the stories he shared with me.
--
Story: Episodes of Aging
I remember being in the backseat of my parents' car. I was engulfed by warm maroon fabric. My view of the grey October sky was obstructed by the monolithic front seats. I remember being unhappy and launching into a tantrum. I shrieked and slammed my head repeatedly against the foam backing of the bench seat. Each time I struck it, the foam sprung my head back forward. I even remember the tugging of my cheeks upon my face as the fleshy pockets lagged behind. I returned the volley with a snap of my little neck. My mother remained impervious to the siege, but my father eventually turned around.
"Do you have any idea how unpleasant you are making this trip for mom and I?" His tightly-formed lips added velocity to the reprimand. Pierced, I stopped immediately. I forgot the cause of my unhappiness; I was dumbfounded. The frustration in my father's eyes--the outward similarity with the frustration inside of me at the time--transported me to a different perspective. In my mind, I left my body. I pictured myself looking back at my bodily self, red and crying in the backseat. The rhetorical question had revealed for the first time a truth about the human condition. I inadvertently learned that the world contained many viewpoints, not just my own. In a flash, I was ripped from my youthful solipsism. I blinked at the grey sky in the center of my field of vision that had filled in my father's vacancy. I was at once fascinated and frightened. I was not alone and yet I was alone. There were others similar to me, and yet they were not the same. Residual tears glided along my conflicted face to my smooth chin.
What if, instead of realizing that I was but one citizen in the world, I drew a different conclusion? What if I thought instead that I was the only citizen that mattered and that these other people, mere aliens, were obstructions. I would be a very different person.
I remember too feeling certain there were other moms and dads, but only one Mom and one Dad. I remember feeling like the only Brandon in the world. My experience was unique and thus a unique name was appropriate. I liked being original. It had taken me more than five years of life to realize other people had my first name. The other times I had heard the name, they must have glided over me. When in pre-school and I met another Brandon, the name stuck out. As the teacher called roll she said, "Brandon" twice: once for Brandon Baulderling and once for Brandon Hayes--myself. I was dumbfounded. How could someone else be called the same name? It was my name; it defined me. It fixed me in a stable medium of letters. I felt like I lost my identity. I was offended by the possibility of replication. It was my sad introduction to the peculiar staleness of human affairs. After that disappointing pre-school morning, the extent of my unoriginality was often expanded. Everywhere I looked I saw more wearisome similarities. Height was shared; eye color was shared; language was shared. Even my name--the thing I introduced myself with--was not just shared but well-worn. Brandons were wandering all over the world. Years later I ruminated on the extent of my own banality. I was curious as to the number of dead Brandons in the ground, how many women hated their faithless Brandons, and how many men would take a bullet for their loyal Brandons. I did not like sharing then, and in ways I do not like sharing now. It made me feel like my portion of human dignity was diminished every time the population increased. The only benefit with time is that I can now articulate my feelings more clearly. I feel frequently lost in obscurity, as a zebra must within a pack of his siblings.
What if, rather than be humbled by my commonality with other people, I drew a different conclusion? What if I became determined to distinguish myself and be the penultimate Brandon? I would be a very different person.
--
What has Brandon told us about aging? See how smoothly the younger becomes the older? The movement which was so contrary when viewed from without is quite concordant from within. The person of yesterday hands off life to the person of tomorrow like a baton in a marathon. The thread of personal history ties a self together.
Here again we find that time is crucial. What we have seen makes us who we are. If Brandon had not had a classmate with his name until kindergarten (instead of pre-school), would he have been more prepared? Would it not have debilitated him?
In trying to answer one question we raise others. Why did Brandon draw the conclusions he did rather than the others he considered later (or any of the others he did not consider, for surely there are plenty of conclusions he could have left with)? Little Brandon had not aged enough to make a fully informed choice about it. He could not weigh the outcomes. He simply reacted. Could it be a random response? Could it be instead the result of some mood already established earlier in the day? Ought we circle back further towards earlier and earlier times that Brandon cannot remember, like scalding hot milk in a bottle or the warmth of a wool sweater on his face? Does the explanation of self end in tail chasing? The specter of irrationality drifts into view. How ever are we to come to an answer? We have muddled things thoroughly despite seeking clarity. How murky the human experience!
Brandon Hayes, whom I've introduced you to before, generously answered in writing a question I posed to him regarding aging. I asked him what events sprang to mind when he thought of his childhood. Below are the stories he shared with me.
--
Story: Episodes of Aging
I remember being in the backseat of my parents' car. I was engulfed by warm maroon fabric. My view of the grey October sky was obstructed by the monolithic front seats. I remember being unhappy and launching into a tantrum. I shrieked and slammed my head repeatedly against the foam backing of the bench seat. Each time I struck it, the foam sprung my head back forward. I even remember the tugging of my cheeks upon my face as the fleshy pockets lagged behind. I returned the volley with a snap of my little neck. My mother remained impervious to the siege, but my father eventually turned around.
"Do you have any idea how unpleasant you are making this trip for mom and I?" His tightly-formed lips added velocity to the reprimand. Pierced, I stopped immediately. I forgot the cause of my unhappiness; I was dumbfounded. The frustration in my father's eyes--the outward similarity with the frustration inside of me at the time--transported me to a different perspective. In my mind, I left my body. I pictured myself looking back at my bodily self, red and crying in the backseat. The rhetorical question had revealed for the first time a truth about the human condition. I inadvertently learned that the world contained many viewpoints, not just my own. In a flash, I was ripped from my youthful solipsism. I blinked at the grey sky in the center of my field of vision that had filled in my father's vacancy. I was at once fascinated and frightened. I was not alone and yet I was alone. There were others similar to me, and yet they were not the same. Residual tears glided along my conflicted face to my smooth chin.
What if, instead of realizing that I was but one citizen in the world, I drew a different conclusion? What if I thought instead that I was the only citizen that mattered and that these other people, mere aliens, were obstructions. I would be a very different person.
I remember too feeling certain there were other moms and dads, but only one Mom and one Dad. I remember feeling like the only Brandon in the world. My experience was unique and thus a unique name was appropriate. I liked being original. It had taken me more than five years of life to realize other people had my first name. The other times I had heard the name, they must have glided over me. When in pre-school and I met another Brandon, the name stuck out. As the teacher called roll she said, "Brandon" twice: once for Brandon Baulderling and once for Brandon Hayes--myself. I was dumbfounded. How could someone else be called the same name? It was my name; it defined me. It fixed me in a stable medium of letters. I felt like I lost my identity. I was offended by the possibility of replication. It was my sad introduction to the peculiar staleness of human affairs. After that disappointing pre-school morning, the extent of my unoriginality was often expanded. Everywhere I looked I saw more wearisome similarities. Height was shared; eye color was shared; language was shared. Even my name--the thing I introduced myself with--was not just shared but well-worn. Brandons were wandering all over the world. Years later I ruminated on the extent of my own banality. I was curious as to the number of dead Brandons in the ground, how many women hated their faithless Brandons, and how many men would take a bullet for their loyal Brandons. I did not like sharing then, and in ways I do not like sharing now. It made me feel like my portion of human dignity was diminished every time the population increased. The only benefit with time is that I can now articulate my feelings more clearly. I feel frequently lost in obscurity, as a zebra must within a pack of his siblings.
What if, rather than be humbled by my commonality with other people, I drew a different conclusion? What if I became determined to distinguish myself and be the penultimate Brandon? I would be a very different person.
--
What has Brandon told us about aging? See how smoothly the younger becomes the older? The movement which was so contrary when viewed from without is quite concordant from within. The person of yesterday hands off life to the person of tomorrow like a baton in a marathon. The thread of personal history ties a self together.
Here again we find that time is crucial. What we have seen makes us who we are. If Brandon had not had a classmate with his name until kindergarten (instead of pre-school), would he have been more prepared? Would it not have debilitated him?
In trying to answer one question we raise others. Why did Brandon draw the conclusions he did rather than the others he considered later (or any of the others he did not consider, for surely there are plenty of conclusions he could have left with)? Little Brandon had not aged enough to make a fully informed choice about it. He could not weigh the outcomes. He simply reacted. Could it be a random response? Could it be instead the result of some mood already established earlier in the day? Ought we circle back further towards earlier and earlier times that Brandon cannot remember, like scalding hot milk in a bottle or the warmth of a wool sweater on his face? Does the explanation of self end in tail chasing? The specter of irrationality drifts into view. How ever are we to come to an answer? We have muddled things thoroughly despite seeking clarity. How murky the human experience!
Monday, December 28, 2009
Growth: The Physics of Aging
A man walks through a store with his child tucked safely in his arm. The child leans over and grabs indiscriminately at passing products. The colors and shapes captivate her. The father keeps his child at a distance from her tempters. He moves with purpose past these possibilities back to the area of the store where the product his family needs is located. The father picks up the related products and grabs at the price tags. Cost per ounce, percentage of active ingredients--the numbers captivate him. He selects the winning competitor after comparing the potency in his mind.
Watch this sequence of events--or any other one involving parents and their offspring. Think that only some twenty years hence the same sort of event may be played out again, only the person who was in the role of the child may being the one playing the role of the parent. What is the link between children and adults? How many links are there between the two and how many lie severed on the floor between them?
Difficult questions need to be meticulously analyzed to be answered: examine the pieces separately, gain an understanding of them, and then a person can put forth a solution.
Vision is an immediate means of examination. People see in pictures, a series of fluidly changing images. Sight is always framed by a perimeter which gives every waking perception a limited dimension. The scale is amenable to human consumption. Is it any wonder that people often think in images as well? Pictorial thinking is manageable--like playing a game. There are boundaries and easily defined relations between the aspects of the image (i.e., the rules of a game). With the aid of pictorial thinking--a simple metaphor for an elaborate subject--something that was big is made small and what was confusing is now understood. A person paints a picture of something profound in life, shows it to his audience, and can now say, "There, I have made the big small for you." The artist has served his audience and releases his authority over his creation when he publicizes it. The audience is free to consider the work, critique it, leave it behind, or order a print.
Picture: Elevators
I take up my thought brush and paint thusly for you, my dear audience. The lives of people are like a set of adjacent elevators: as one elevator drops, the strain on the cord causes the other elevator to rise. One elevator is pure potential. One elevator is actuality--is being. Thus, when a person is conceived the actuality elevator is on the ground floor. Never can it go lower. The potential elevator is at the top of the building. Never can it go higher.
The little one, our exemplary individual, begins within the potential elevator. She can be anything at all. Potential is pristine, free from the taint of error. It is perfect in its vacuity. Naturally, the audience (I presume) thinks of the best of possibilities--the lawyer, the doctor, the president! Oh! Hope of hopes--what if she could be the leader of the free world? Time will tell.
The elevators operate on a time schedule. As the days go by, the potential elevator drops and the little one develops. Like grains of sand, the little one trickles into the elevator of actuality. Reality is defiant, stand-offish, proud of its dimensions and girth. It is noble in its density. The individual becomes something real and thorough, something fleshed out. She comes down to earth. The child learns a certain language, grows to a certain height, sees certain things, and so on. The actuality elevator rises as she ages. She becomes perhaps a student, a lover, a parent of her own. At some point the elevators meet. For a tenuous moment they are equal. The person whose life is pictured by the set of elevators now is fairly divided between the two. An instant later, disequilibrium returns. Now, more of her leaves the potential elevator and steps aboard the actual one. She is now ready to be more actual than potential. With the next moment, the tragedy comes--she realizes that the more she becomes, the less she can be! Oh! Terror of terrors--what if she has become the wrong sort of thing? The audience worries about the worst of possibilities--to be a failure, a vagrant, a disgrace. Whatever she is, it is impossible to change course. The elevators only move in one direction as time only moves forward. She becomes tired; her body aches. The prospect of deviating from habit or searching beyond the familiar confines distress her. Downward plunges what the person can become as who she actually is rises higher and higher. If the mistakes are too many or too great, the image is eerily reminiscent of an execution. The height kills. But if the triumphs have piled up, the image is of a catapult. The load is delivered unto the heavens. When she reaches the top, at the end of her life, the doors open, the cord is severed, and what was rushes to earth in a race to become nothing.
The audience wonders, what floor has she reached? Did she walk out? Is the ride simply over?
As the artist, I have the luxury of being coy. I can refrain from expanding upon my work and drawing out implications I think would infringe upon the responsibilities of the audience. I will say, though, that here I have painted a picture of life that is principally defined by time. In this way, childhood and adulthood are opposed. The contents of the elevators are inversely proportional. A person becomes less like a child the more like an adult he becomes. There is truth in this, is there not? One may look at life through time like a lens. Then the link between childhood and adulthood is a loose one because one has stepped outside of a life to look at a life.
Potentiality, with childhood as its representative, is the antithesis to actuality, with adulthood as its representative. Potentiality is open because it is empty. The distinction between potentiality and nothing is that we expect the former to become something else whereas we expect the latter to remain the same, to remain nothing. There is something there when we consider potentiality, however undeveloped. We press the raw material into molds or press stamps onto it. Now, it is or contains something else, it is formed. Actuality is binding because it is full. It resists alteration because of its structure, though it too can be undone.
This picture is weighty, is it not? Does it not saddle you down? It adds a great, painful, anxiety-inducing gravity to all of one's time because it paints imprisonment as so inescapable. Life is a process of binding. Being bound is what makes life like a gamble, for once the bet has been placed (i.e., the choice made) there is always a record of it and a consequential reckoning. Once a person has gambled wrongly, it impoverishes him. He takes that err with him in the form of an empty pocket, whether or not he remembers why he is poor. He never escapes it. He wriggles on the pin of failure. It is as though all moments of time impale a person and fix them at that point. Could it be that all these frozen people are what push the elevator of actuality downwards--that keep one from rising higher and faster? What heights could a person attain, how tall would the building of his life be, if not for all these instantaneous duplications! Is it possible that all the people a person has been are pinned onto this latest person? Oh how the woman now is different than the baby she was--that little balloon so scantly adorned!
Do not despair. We are looking out from time and time is ambivalent in the abstract. A person might just as easily be lifted up by her becoming. It is after all the natural motion of the elevator of becoming to move upwards. In potentiality there is freedom. What if a child took the advice of a beneficent mentor and developed a talent for piano instead of listening to his friends encourage him to vandalize? How many times does a person, going upwards, have the opportunity to become something they would approve of in quiet reflection--away from peers? Yes, life is a process of trial and error, of learning the truth of things from within them after assessing the truth of them from without them. So long as there is some depth for the potential elevator to descend into, there is still hope. Would it not be enough for a person to renege on her shameful missteps just prior to the door opening? Could she not shed those copies of herself that constrained her? In ways yes and in ways no, but if I elaborated I would be leaving my picture behind and moving somewhere else.
Watch this sequence of events--or any other one involving parents and their offspring. Think that only some twenty years hence the same sort of event may be played out again, only the person who was in the role of the child may being the one playing the role of the parent. What is the link between children and adults? How many links are there between the two and how many lie severed on the floor between them?
Difficult questions need to be meticulously analyzed to be answered: examine the pieces separately, gain an understanding of them, and then a person can put forth a solution.
Vision is an immediate means of examination. People see in pictures, a series of fluidly changing images. Sight is always framed by a perimeter which gives every waking perception a limited dimension. The scale is amenable to human consumption. Is it any wonder that people often think in images as well? Pictorial thinking is manageable--like playing a game. There are boundaries and easily defined relations between the aspects of the image (i.e., the rules of a game). With the aid of pictorial thinking--a simple metaphor for an elaborate subject--something that was big is made small and what was confusing is now understood. A person paints a picture of something profound in life, shows it to his audience, and can now say, "There, I have made the big small for you." The artist has served his audience and releases his authority over his creation when he publicizes it. The audience is free to consider the work, critique it, leave it behind, or order a print.
Picture: Elevators
I take up my thought brush and paint thusly for you, my dear audience. The lives of people are like a set of adjacent elevators: as one elevator drops, the strain on the cord causes the other elevator to rise. One elevator is pure potential. One elevator is actuality--is being. Thus, when a person is conceived the actuality elevator is on the ground floor. Never can it go lower. The potential elevator is at the top of the building. Never can it go higher.
The little one, our exemplary individual, begins within the potential elevator. She can be anything at all. Potential is pristine, free from the taint of error. It is perfect in its vacuity. Naturally, the audience (I presume) thinks of the best of possibilities--the lawyer, the doctor, the president! Oh! Hope of hopes--what if she could be the leader of the free world? Time will tell.
The elevators operate on a time schedule. As the days go by, the potential elevator drops and the little one develops. Like grains of sand, the little one trickles into the elevator of actuality. Reality is defiant, stand-offish, proud of its dimensions and girth. It is noble in its density. The individual becomes something real and thorough, something fleshed out. She comes down to earth. The child learns a certain language, grows to a certain height, sees certain things, and so on. The actuality elevator rises as she ages. She becomes perhaps a student, a lover, a parent of her own. At some point the elevators meet. For a tenuous moment they are equal. The person whose life is pictured by the set of elevators now is fairly divided between the two. An instant later, disequilibrium returns. Now, more of her leaves the potential elevator and steps aboard the actual one. She is now ready to be more actual than potential. With the next moment, the tragedy comes--she realizes that the more she becomes, the less she can be! Oh! Terror of terrors--what if she has become the wrong sort of thing? The audience worries about the worst of possibilities--to be a failure, a vagrant, a disgrace. Whatever she is, it is impossible to change course. The elevators only move in one direction as time only moves forward. She becomes tired; her body aches. The prospect of deviating from habit or searching beyond the familiar confines distress her. Downward plunges what the person can become as who she actually is rises higher and higher. If the mistakes are too many or too great, the image is eerily reminiscent of an execution. The height kills. But if the triumphs have piled up, the image is of a catapult. The load is delivered unto the heavens. When she reaches the top, at the end of her life, the doors open, the cord is severed, and what was rushes to earth in a race to become nothing.
The audience wonders, what floor has she reached? Did she walk out? Is the ride simply over?
As the artist, I have the luxury of being coy. I can refrain from expanding upon my work and drawing out implications I think would infringe upon the responsibilities of the audience. I will say, though, that here I have painted a picture of life that is principally defined by time. In this way, childhood and adulthood are opposed. The contents of the elevators are inversely proportional. A person becomes less like a child the more like an adult he becomes. There is truth in this, is there not? One may look at life through time like a lens. Then the link between childhood and adulthood is a loose one because one has stepped outside of a life to look at a life.
Potentiality, with childhood as its representative, is the antithesis to actuality, with adulthood as its representative. Potentiality is open because it is empty. The distinction between potentiality and nothing is that we expect the former to become something else whereas we expect the latter to remain the same, to remain nothing. There is something there when we consider potentiality, however undeveloped. We press the raw material into molds or press stamps onto it. Now, it is or contains something else, it is formed. Actuality is binding because it is full. It resists alteration because of its structure, though it too can be undone.
This picture is weighty, is it not? Does it not saddle you down? It adds a great, painful, anxiety-inducing gravity to all of one's time because it paints imprisonment as so inescapable. Life is a process of binding. Being bound is what makes life like a gamble, for once the bet has been placed (i.e., the choice made) there is always a record of it and a consequential reckoning. Once a person has gambled wrongly, it impoverishes him. He takes that err with him in the form of an empty pocket, whether or not he remembers why he is poor. He never escapes it. He wriggles on the pin of failure. It is as though all moments of time impale a person and fix them at that point. Could it be that all these frozen people are what push the elevator of actuality downwards--that keep one from rising higher and faster? What heights could a person attain, how tall would the building of his life be, if not for all these instantaneous duplications! Is it possible that all the people a person has been are pinned onto this latest person? Oh how the woman now is different than the baby she was--that little balloon so scantly adorned!
Do not despair. We are looking out from time and time is ambivalent in the abstract. A person might just as easily be lifted up by her becoming. It is after all the natural motion of the elevator of becoming to move upwards. In potentiality there is freedom. What if a child took the advice of a beneficent mentor and developed a talent for piano instead of listening to his friends encourage him to vandalize? How many times does a person, going upwards, have the opportunity to become something they would approve of in quiet reflection--away from peers? Yes, life is a process of trial and error, of learning the truth of things from within them after assessing the truth of them from without them. So long as there is some depth for the potential elevator to descend into, there is still hope. Would it not be enough for a person to renege on her shameful missteps just prior to the door opening? Could she not shed those copies of herself that constrained her? In ways yes and in ways no, but if I elaborated I would be leaving my picture behind and moving somewhere else.
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
Drifting
I feel like a child whose balloon has escaped into the sky. Unlike a child, I am not wailing. Instead, I am watching it shrink as it rises and wondering whether it is so lamentable. The gifts we receive in life can be like balloons handed to us as children. Though we adore their marvelous color and gravity-defining, rarely can we manage a lasting hold on it. We look away at another child passing by or towards the origin of screams coming from a nearby amusement ride. Our fingers open ever so slightly for want of concentration, and our balloon takes flight. "It was meant for the sky, not for you," says the grizzled grandfather. "There are other balloons," says the consoling father. "We'll get you another one," says the sympathetic mother. Sometimes we lack the motivation to jump after it, anticipating the futility of the action. Sometimes, we mourn the loss by swearing off balloons. I am simply gazing at it and making note of its bearings. So this is the way balloons leave: east, then northeast, but always up.
I am older now and realize I am still holding other strings even though one recently snuck out. Until we die, we are always holding at least one pretty thing on a string. Some children want to look up at what is lost and cry. The wiser ones blow it a goodbye kiss.
I am older now and realize I am still holding other strings even though one recently snuck out. Until we die, we are always holding at least one pretty thing on a string. Some children want to look up at what is lost and cry. The wiser ones blow it a goodbye kiss.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)